Gaming Media: Accessibility versus Accountability

It’s getting really hard to find an honest review of AAA titles.  Take Dragon Age II for example: at Metacritic, all three versions made it onto a list of titles with much lower user reviews than critic reviews.  While user reviews are far from a scientific measurement, the experiences of metacritic users certainly seem more in line with my experience with DAII than the professional critics who awarded the highest rating.  I also find it a bit suspicious that the critics from high traffic sites I’ve heard of tend to rate these AAA games higher than the critics I’m unfamiliar with.

I’m not accusing gaming journalists of taking bribes.  I don’t like conspiracy theories and don’t think anything that blatant is necessary to create this effect.  What I do think is happening is one of the same things that seems to be affecting mainstream media in relation to such topics as politics.  Journalists, or more likely their employers, seem loathe to openly criticize groups which they need access to in order to report the news their competitors are reporting which their viewers want.  In mainstream media, this concern plays out by limiting criticism of politicians or entire parties in order to get that front row press conference seat.

I’m sure it plays out a little differently in gaming journalism.  I’m not willing to say that positive reviews of Dragon Age II that completely ignore its faults are all results of reviewers that were afraid to lose access to free review copies, beta tests, and tours of developers’ studios.  However, I have to wonder if those perks create an unconscious positive bias toward a product, an unconscious tendency to give their friends a little bit more of a break.  They seem to save the more objective or more honest reviews for the indie products.

Gaming Journalism appears to struggle between maintaining accessibility to the content providers, the game developers and publishers, versus maintaining accountability to consumers, the intended audience of the reviews.

Unfortunately, it makes so many of these news sites only useful for hype — sure, they toured X studio and can talk about future products X,Y, and Z, but once those products are actually released, I feel the need to dig quite a bit deeper to find objectivity.


3 responses to “Gaming Media: Accessibility versus Accountability

  1. Your comments about Global Agenda really nail it. While a game like that needs to be relatively moderate in graphics content in order to be more accessible to the general gaming community, I feel they do somewhat of an injustice to gaming potential in general. After all, I see many MMORPG’s out there with hundreds of thousands of people playing at once, and the experience isn’t hindered in spite of the heavy graphics. I think games like Global Agenda, Star Siege Tribes, and the like sacrifice quality on the alter of perceived mediocrity. Most gamers will see a game that demands intense graphics and clamor to frankenstien their machines into something that can handle it. I say crank it up, game developers. Don’t worry about us. We’ll find a way.

    • I like graphics, but I prefer interesting game play. I can’t say for sure that GA has interesting game play or not since I haven’t spent much time in it, though I do think that twitch combat makes performance more of an issue than the standard auto-attack hotkey combat in most MMOs.

      But you’re right. PC gamers will generally find a way. In college, I sold my PS2 and games just to buy a new video card for some release or another. And of course, PC games give a lot more control over video quality and detail — so just because not every system can handle the graphics cranked doesn’t mean there should not be an option to crank them.

      • I also feel that game play is MOST important overall. I guess my point was if you’re not going to give the game a decent story, please give us eye candy! Consider a game like DiRT. There isn’t a story per se (unless you count all the “great job!” comments after you finish each race to open new content), but I can almost overlook game play as a whole because it(Dirt 3 in particular) is just stunning in graphic detail.

        Keep these posts coming. I appreciate your perspective.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s